Season 4

Native Texans Connie Hilton and her husband George Newman moved out to rural Tyler, TX. Very early one morning in September 1990, their peaceful country life is abruptly and brutally shattered.

In March 1987, college student and aspiring teacher Tammy Crowe has everything, including a loving family, a devoted boyfriend, and a promising future; however, on her way to a friend's dinner party, Tammy's life takes a devastating and violent turn.

After 15-year-old Jasmine Block mysteriously vanishes into thin air, her mother Sarah launches a crusade to find her before it's too late. But when the sickening truth behind Jasmine's disappearance surfaces, it leaves Sarah in shock.

After Allison Walker mysteriously goes missing just days before Christmas, investigators scour her pig farm in Adairville, KY, in search of clues. They quickly discover that the deep, dark secret to her whereabouts lies within her own family.

When Lisa Holden has a baby, gets married and then moves to an isolated home in rural Ben Wheeler, TX, it triggers a long, inexplicable estrangement from her family. But at the root of this painful divide lies something far more evil than her family could ever imagine.

To pay for college in the summer of 1979, Donna Ferres takes a job working the overnight shift at a local convenience store in Glen Burnie, MD. But after a familiar face walks into the store one night, her routine shift takes a sick and twisted turn.

After getting engaged, Nikki Ansley takes a job at a local convenience store to pay for her upcoming nuptials. But her best-laid plans are horrifically derailed when two unwelcome customers show up right before closing time.

After a young Native American woman is found brutalized and clinging to life on the side of a rural Montana road, her family and authorities seek answers. Their search for justice leads them down a shocking, sickening, and devastating road.

When 16-year-old aspiring film producer Bohdi Potter and her boyfriend go missing, the grave truth behind their disappearance lies deep in the hollow corridors and dark caverns of an old, abandoned military bunker.

Between her upcoming wedding, a new home, and a thriving real estate career, it looks like everything in Lori Brown's life is headed in the right direction. But one fateful Monday afternoon, her life takes an unforeseeable and tragic turn.

In the mid-to-late 1990s, a sexual predator police dub "The Blue Light Rapist" goes on a serial attack spree across Arkansas. As authorities scramble to stop him in his tracks, he sets his sights on seventeen-year-old Shannon Woods.

A troubled young man befriends Jessica Vega via social media, and the kind-hearted college student and single mom does her best to steer him towards a better path. Unfortunately, her good intentions will soon come back to haunt her.